perf(mcp): answer-directly steering — ~35% cheaper, ~70% fewer tool calls (#224)

* perf(mcp): steer agents to answer directly instead of delegating to subagents

CodeGraph beats native grep/read on cost only when the agent queries it
directly. When the agent delegates to file-reading sub-agents, those
sub-agents read files regardless of the index, so CodeGraph becomes net
overhead on top of the reads. The install templates even told agents to
"spawn a subagent for explore-class questions" — the expensive path.

Changes:
- server-instructions + both install templates: add an "Answer directly —
  don't delegate exploration" directive; reposition codegraph_explore as the
  efficient one-call multi-symbol tool (was: "spawn a subagent for it").
- codegraph_explore: hard-cap output to its adaptive budget (it overran,
  ~30k vs a 28k cap) and tighten the medium tier (28k->13k).
- codegraph_node: return a member outline for container kinds instead of the
  full class body.

Rigorous N>=4-per-arm warm-block benchmark (median total_cost_usd):
  excalidraw (~600 files):  WITH $0.54 vs native $1.02  (-47%)
  vscode     (~10k files):  WITH $0.41 vs native $0.72  (-42%)
  ky         (~25 files):   WITH $0.46 vs native $0.44  (wash)
Answers were equal-or-better (correct, file:line-cited) with ~6x fewer tool
calls; the directive drove the direct path on 14/14 codegraph runs.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

* docs(readme): rebuild benchmark with real-world repos + cost/token/time/tool savings

Replace the "Claude Code (Python+Rust/Java)" rows — which benchmarked the
Claude Code CLI repo, not real codebases in those languages — with real
open-source projects per language: Django (Python), Tokio (Rust), OkHttp
(Java), Gin (Go), plus Alamofire (Swift) and the existing TypeScript repos
(VS Code, Excalidraw).

The table now reports all four savings the change targets — cost, tokens,
time, tool calls — as the median of 4 runs per arm (Claude Opus 4.7,
headless claude -p, with vs empty MCP config). Averages across the 7 repos:
35% cheaper, 59% fewer tokens, 49% faster, 70% fewer tool calls. Adds a
methodology note and raw WITH->WITHOUT medians.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>

---------

Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
Colby Mchenry
2026-05-20 16:33:50 -05:00
committed by GitHub
co-authored by Claude Opus 4.7
parent a47355780b
commit f5bbc26c60
6 changed files with 152 additions and 65 deletions
+25 -1
View File
@@ -33,6 +33,25 @@ and adheres to [Semantic Versioning](https://semver.org/spec/v2.0.0.html).
setup is actually fast. `codegraph uninit` removes any hooks it installed.
### Changed
- **MCP / agent guidance**: CodeGraph now tells agents to answer "how does X
work" / architecture questions *directly*`codegraph_context`, then one
`codegraph_explore` for the surfaced symbols — instead of delegating to a
file-reading sub-agent or a grep+read loop. The server instructions and the
installed instruction files (`CLAUDE.md`, `.cursor/rules/codegraph.mdc`,
`AGENTS.md`) previously suggested *spawning a sub-agent* for explore-class
questions, which produced the opposite, more expensive behavior: the
sub-agent reads files regardless of the index, so CodeGraph became overhead
stacked on top of the reads. In rigorous N≥4-per-arm benchmarks this cut the
cost of an architecture question by ~4247% versus a no-CodeGraph agent on
medium and large repos (Excalidraw ~600 files, VS Code ~10k), with
equal-or-better, `file:line`-cited answers and ~6× fewer tool calls; on a
tiny repo (~25 files) it's a wash, since native grep is already trivially
cheap there.
- **MCP / codegraph_node**: `includeCode=true` on a class/interface/struct/enum
now returns a compact member outline (fields + method signatures + line
numbers) instead of the entire class body — which could be thousands of
characters and was rarely needed in full. Functions and methods still return
their full body; request a specific member for its source.
- **Minimum Node.js is now 20** (was 18). Node 18 is end-of-life and the
native SQLite binding (`better-sqlite3` 12.x) no longer ships a Node 18
prebuilt binary. Node 22 LTS and Node 24 get the native backend out of the
@@ -48,7 +67,7 @@ and adheres to [Semantic Versioning](https://semver.org/spec/v2.0.0.html).
now scales with indexed file count: small projects (<500 files) cap at
~18KB and skip the "Additional relevant files" / completeness / explore-
budget reminders that earn their keep on bigger codebases; medium
(<5,000) caps at ~28KB; large (<15,000) keeps the historical ~35KB; very
(<5,000) caps at ~13KB; large (<15,000) keeps the historical ~35KB; very
large goes up to ~38KB. A new per-file char cap also prevents a single
file with many adjacent symbols from collapsing into one whole-file dump
(the Alamofire `Session.swift` case from #185). Per-file cluster
@@ -63,6 +82,11 @@ and adheres to [Semantic Versioning](https://semver.org/spec/v2.0.0.html).
Thanks to [@essopsp](https://github.com/essopsp) for the repro.
### Fixed
- **MCP / explore**: `codegraph_explore` output is now hard-capped to its
adaptive size budget. It could previously overrun (e.g. ~30K against a 28K
cap) once the relationship map and trailer sections were appended; the
oversized payload then sat in the agent's context and was re-read on every
later turn.
- **Sync / status**: git-untracked files are no longer reported as pending
"Added" forever. After `codegraph sync` indexed a newly-created untracked
source file, `codegraph status` kept listing it under Pending Changes and