fix(rust): resolve self.field.method() on the field's declared type instead of a same-named method (#1585) (#1599)
Fixes #1585. **Stacked on #1596** (the base branch is `fix/1588-rust-impl-type-qualification`; this PR's own diff is the second commit). Merge #1596 first, then retarget/merge this one. ## What was wrong ```rust impl Outer { pub fn run(&mut self) { self.inner.run(); // inner: Inner } } ``` produced `Outer::run -> Outer::run` — recursion the source doesn't contain. The extractor collapsed every `self.<field>.<method>()` receiver to the bare method name (`run`), so the resolver only ever saw `run` and exact-matched the nearest same-named method — the calling method itself, or a method of an unrelated type. Nothing marked the edge as a guess, and no row stayed in `unresolved_refs`, so a consumer had no way to tell. The same happened when the field's type isn't a project type at all (`its: std::vec::IntoIter<_>` → `self.its.next()`, `matcher: Regex` → `self.matcher.is_match()`): the bare `next` / `is_match` attached to whatever local method shared the name. ripgrep had 279 self-edges on `main`; the issue lists three sites, all of this shape. (The issue's C++ control — "`Outer::run -> Inner::run` resolves correctly" — doesn't actually hold on `main`: `inner.h` is classified as C by the `.h` heuristic, so `Inner::run` never exists and the C++ repro self-edges too. That's #1592, fixed separately.) ## What this does Rust struct fields are not graph nodes, so the field's type can only come from the struct's declaration text. This follows the Go 2-hop precedent exactly (`matchGoFieldChainCall`, #1276), including its exclusivity rule: 1. **Extraction (TS walker + native kernel, identical, parity-tested):** a call whose receiver is `self.<field>` keeps the owner-field shape — `self.inner.run()` is emitted as `self.inner.run`. Deeper chains (`self.a.b.m()`), call receivers (`self.f().m()`), parenthesized receivers and bare `self` keep the bare name, exactly as before. 2. **Resolution (`matchRustSelfFieldCall`):** owner type = the calling method's qualified-name prefix (`Outer::run` → `Outer`); the field's declared type is read from the owner struct's **own declaration lines** (comment-stripped, line by line — same discipline as the Go helper); the method is resolved **and validated** on that type by `resolveMethodOnType` (confidence 0.85, `instance-method`). 3. **Exclusive:** when the field is declared with an external type, a generic parameter (`T`), a container that doesn't auto-deref (`Option`/`Vec`/`Mutex`/…), or can't be found, the ref **stays unresolved** — it never falls through to the bare-name strategies. That is the safe behaviour the issue asks for, and it is what #1276 already chose for Go. `rustFieldTypeName` looks through exactly the layers Rust's method-call auto-deref looks through: references (`&`, `&'a mut`) and the owning smart pointers `Box`/`Rc`/`Arc`. `Box<dyn Source>` yields the trait, whose method node the interface-impl synthesizer then fans out to every implementation. `Option<Inner>` is left alone — `self.inner.take()` is Option's method and must not become `Inner::take`. Why it stacks on #1596: the owner is taken from the method's qualified name, which for a generic/lifetime impl was the trait's name before that fix. ## Measured on ripgrep (110 `.rs` files, #1596 build vs this branch) | | #1596 | this PR | |---|---|---| | nodes | 4029 | 4029 | | `calls` self-edges | 279 | **146** (none of the `self.<field>` shape remain — 116 bare-receiver, 30 other dotted) | | `self.<field>.m()` calls resolved through a validated field type | — | **292** (`DecompressionMatcher::command -> GlobSet::matches`, `Parser::find_long -> FlagMap::find`, `Haystack::path -> DirEntry::path`, …) | | `self.<field>.m()` calls left unresolved | — | **417** — every sampled one is a std/container method: `self.commands.push`, `self.child.wait`, `self.pre.is_some`, `self.colors.clone`, `self.path_terminator.unwrap_or` | | `calls` edges total | 9150 | 8878 (the 272 removed are the former bare-name guesses for those 417) | The issue's three sites: `walk.rs:824` now resolves to `IgnoreBuilder::add_custom_ignore_filename` (was a self-edge); `walk.rs:1195` (`self.its.next`, `IntoIter`) and `globset/lib.rs:983` (`self.matcher.is_match`, `Regex`) are parked as unresolved instead of guessed. The issue's repro gives `Outer::run -> Inner::run` (`instance-method`, confidence 0.85) on both the kernel path and `CODEGRAPH_KERNEL=0`. ## Tests - `__tests__/extraction.test.ts`: only the single-hop `self.<field>.<method>()` call keeps the prefix; deeper / call / parenthesized / bare-`self` receivers and a local receiver are unchanged. - `__tests__/resolution.test.ts` (end-to-end, Cargo layout): the issue's repro → `Outer::run -> Inner::run`, no self-edge; an external field type (`std::vec::IntoIter`) with a local `next` decoy → no edge at all; `Box<Inner>` and `&'a mut Inner` resolve, `Option<Inner>` does not (even though `Inner` declares the method); a generic `T` field → no edge; genuine `self.run()` recursion keeps its self-edge; the #1588 repro's `UsesFile::go` / `UsesBuf::go` resolve to `FileSource::read` / `BufSource::read`, and a `Box<dyn Source>` field lands on `Source::read` with the synthesizer fanning out to both impls. - `__tests__/fixtures/kernel-parity/torture.rs` grows the receiver shapes; all 15 kernel parity suites pass against the rebuilt kernel (147 tests). - Full `npm test` on this branch: 189 files, 3187 passed, 9 skipped, 0 failed. Re-index after upgrading. 🤖 Generated with [Claude Code](https://claude.com/claude-code) https://claude.ai/code/session_01LxZj6W6Y1SHXwvpT3uwJpK
This commit is contained in:
@@ -4431,6 +4431,26 @@ export class TreeSitterExtractor {
|
||||
} else {
|
||||
calleeName = methodName;
|
||||
}
|
||||
} else if (
|
||||
this.language === 'rust' &&
|
||||
receiver &&
|
||||
receiver.type === 'field_expression' &&
|
||||
getChildByField(receiver, 'value')?.type === 'self' &&
|
||||
getChildByField(receiver, 'field')?.type === 'field_identifier'
|
||||
) {
|
||||
// Rust `self.<field>.<method>()` — a call through a field of the
|
||||
// enclosing type (#1585). Keep the `self.` prefix: the resolver
|
||||
// recognizes the shape, reads the field's declared type off the
|
||||
// owner struct's declaration, and resolves the method on THAT
|
||||
// type — or leaves the ref unresolved when the type is external
|
||||
// or unknown. Previously this collapsed to the bare method name,
|
||||
// which exact-matched whichever same-named method was nearest —
|
||||
// often the calling method itself, a self-edge not in the source.
|
||||
// Deeper chains (`self.a.b.m()`), `self.f().m()` and parenthesized
|
||||
// receivers keep the bare name. Mirrored in the kernel's
|
||||
// extract_call (rustlang.rs).
|
||||
const fieldName = getNodeText(getChildByField(receiver, 'field')!, this.source);
|
||||
calleeName = `self.${fieldName}.${methodName}`;
|
||||
} else if (
|
||||
(this.language === 'cpp' ||
|
||||
this.language === 'c' ||
|
||||
|
||||
Reference in New Issue
Block a user